All-Clad Ha1 vs Ns1 Cookware

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

All Clad Ha1 vs Ns1

Graphic by fivestarslist.com

All-Clad pioneered the use of bonded metal in cookware manufacturing back in 1971, which combined the heat conductivity of aluminum with the durability and low-maintenance convenience of stainless steel. This was a game-changer, and even 50 years later, the Pennsylvania-based company remains the gold standard in high-quality cookware. However, over the intervening decades, the brand’s offerings have expanded significantly. As trends and advances in design and manufacturing have developed, product lines have come and gone.

Nowadays, there are not just one, two, or three options but over half a dozen to choose from. If you’re in the market for a new pan or cookware set, whether for yourself or as a gift, it can be overwhelming to decide which one to go for. In this article, we will take a closer look between two sets – Ha1 and Ns1 – and help you decide which one is a better option for you.

All-Clad is a well-known American brand that manufactures a line of non-stick cookware primarily in China. This line has a model classification that differs from the standard non-stick version, which has led many people to be confused about their differences. One area of confusion is between All-Clad Ha1 and NS1 cookware sets. At first glance, they may appear identical to untrained eyes, but upon closer inspection, their shapes vary significantly. In this article, we will take a closer look at their differences, pros and cons, and help you decide which one is right for your kitchen and household.

Quick Summary of Both Cookware Sets – All-Clad Ha1 and All-Clad Ns1
Categories All-Clad NS1 All-Clad HA1
Performance of Cookware Great Performance Good Performance
Metal Utensil Safe No No
Weight of Cookware Mid-Weight Mid-Weight
Warranty of Cookware Lifetime Warranty Lifetime Warranty
Colors of Cookware Hard-Anodized Hard-Anodized
Stove Top All Stove Top (Including Induction) All Stove Top (Including Induction)
Awareness of Brand American Brand American Brand
Country of Manufacturer Made in China Made in China
Quick Thoughts This appears to be a replica of All-Clad’s mainline series, with the only difference being that it’s made of hard-anodized aluminum. In terms of performance, it outshines the HA1 and is preferred over the HA1 series overall. All Clad’s non-stick cookware is one of their most popular products, but its unique shape can make it challenging to cook with. This design is exclusive to this series and not used in any other All Clad products.

Shared Features of All-Clad Ha1 and All-Clad Ns1

Hard Anodized Aluminum

Anodizing is a technique used to enhance the oxide layer on metals, and many people share videos of this process online. By applying an electric current to the metal in a water bath, the result is a transformed color of the metal, and it’s possible to attach different materials to the outer layer of the metal. For instance, many copper-plated items you see have undergone this process, where copper powder is used to achieve the desired color. It’s worth noting that these coatings aren’t permanent and will eventually wear out over time.
At first glance, a hard-anodized, non-stick pan appears to have been coated with a non-stick finish. However, some sources suggest that it’s actually more long-lasting than a traditional Teflon coating. It’s possible that this is not true, and for this reason, we recommend that you find additional information on anodizing.

Handle of Both Cookware

Despite numerous complaints from customers, All-Clad has not yet addressed the uncomfortable handle on their products. Some have even dubbed it the ‘Mark of All-Clad’ because of how easily it can burn your hand. Unfortunately, this is still an ongoing issue for those who purchase their products. We hope the company will fix the issue in the future.

Base of Stainless Steel on Both Cookware

This product includes a stainless steel base, which is not typically the first choice for cookware due to its poor heat conductivity. However, the manufacturer chose this material for two reasons. Firstly, it’s more resistant to warping than aluminum due to its greater hardness. Secondly, the stainless steel base enables the cookware to be used with induction stovetops, which have become increasingly popular. While a fully-clad aluminum pan may be more appealing to some, the manufacturer opted for the stainless steel base to reduce costs with this line. No matter the reason for the company’s decision, the material has its pros and cons.

Oven and Dish Washer Safety of Both Cookware

Both of these pans possess highly desirable features. They are dishwasher-safe, making clean-up a breeze and eliminating a common complaint about cookware. Additionally, their metal handles make it safe to finish cooking in the oven without the need to transfer the food to a separate dish. Overall, these features make these pans an excellent choice for those seeking convenient and versatile cookware options.

The Differences Between All-Clad Ha1 and All-Clad Ns1

When comparing the two skillets side by side, the construction is nearly identical. They are both constructed with hard-anodized aluminum and feature a stainless steel base. However, the primary difference lies in their shape, with both the pots and frying pans varying in design. We will discuss all these differences and prices in more detail.

All-Clad Ns1 Cookware Set

The NS1 cookware set features pots and pans that maintain the same shape as the main stainless steel version. However, the frying pan boasts lowered sides and rolled lips, which make it more convenient to turn food and pour liquids. All-Clad’s skillet design is widely considered to be near-perfect, so any deviation from this design is likely to be seen as a step back.

In contrast, the pots in the NS1 set share the same simple and functional design as traditional stainless steel cookware, with a straight shape and curved lip. This is a significant improvement over the narrow opening of the HA1 pots.

The Shape of All-Clad Ha1 Cookware

The HA1 frying pan takes its design cues from the traditional French skillet, with a straight edge that’s great for tossing food. However, the taller sides make it difficult to turn food with a spatula and prevent efficient evaporation of liquid. Additionally, the sidewalls seem unusually thick, making the pan appear “fat,” and the lack of a rolled lip makes pouring liquids a challenge.

In contrast, the pots in the HA1 series have a strange curvature to them, with the base being wider than the rim. This is an uncommon design choice, as most manufacturers opt for a smaller base to save on manufacturing costs. Unfortunately, the narrow opening that results from this design makes cooking more challenging. It’s worth noting that All-Clad’s stainless steel line uses a completely different shape.

The Difference Between Lids On Both Cookware

Another difference between the two lines is the type of lid included. The HA1 comes with a glass lid, which allows you to see inside the pot or pan while cooking. However, once steam builds up, the lid can become useless, and there’s also a risk of it shattering. On the other hand, the NS1 comes with a metal lid, which is more durable and eliminates the risk of breakage.

The Price of Both Cookware

The prices of both items are similar, although the NS1 is a bit pricier. Nevertheless, I don’t mind paying the extra cost since it’s more practical. On the other hand, the ha1 series has been subjected to cost-cutting techniques. The reduction in pot size is an attempt to save money on metal, which, unfortunately, makes cooking more challenging. As for the NS1, it has been modeled after their classic cookware, which features a universally appealing design and comes with a metal lid. Despite this, it’s perplexing why the NS1 cookware seems to be increasingly hard to come by.

The Alternatives For Both Cookware

It’s wiser to invest in the mainline stainless steel cookware, which is more robust, and the stainless steel lining is long-lasting. When it comes to non-stick pans, once the coating wears out, it must be replaced, no matter what. You could go for a cheaper T-Fal pan, but if you prefer All Clad’s design and performance, then these pans are a good purchase. You could even get their mainline cookware with a non-stick coating, although those can be quite expensive.

Image source: Amazon Product Advertising API
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.

Last update on 2024-07-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

back to top